Showing posts with label Deforestation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Deforestation. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 10, 2020

When injunction is the norm and not an exception....

The Southern Bench of the National Green Tribunal in a matter relating to a plea to grant stay the celebration of Mahashivarathri at the foothills of the Velliangiri hills located at the elephant corridor. The petitioner believed that lakhs will attend the celebrations disturbing the peaceful existence of wild animals in the area leading to an increase in man-animal conflict in the region. It is indeed surprising that the Tribunal failed to grant a stay of the celebrations even on the preliminary assessment of facts that the venue for conducting the celebrations was indeed within an eco-sensitive region and that there are several petitions against the Isha Foundation pending before various judicial courts in this matter filed every year when the celebrations are due. The plea by the counsel for Isha Foundation that the High Court is seized of the matter and that requisite permissions were already obtained sounds hollow and does not hold water. There is no gainsaying that every year political bigwigs from the ruling party attend the celebrations giving the Foundation much needed publicity. It is therefore, not surprising that there is not a single order against the erring Isha Foundation and the plight of tribals have been sidelined to please the so-called God Man. So, is this dereliction of duty on the part of the National Green Tribunal subsequent to political pressure to connive the illegal activities of the Foundation? It is not clear as to why the lock and seal notice issued against the Foundation not acted upon since 2012, despite state government taking corrective measures against the Foundation. Why was no injunction granted against the construction of 112 feet idol of Lord Shiva on wetlands presumably owned by the Foundation? How did the Foundation even obtain title over land in reserved forest and hill areas? Courts cannot gloss over permissions obtained but examine whether such permissions were within the law and legally appropriate under laws relating to environment protection and forest land use and conversion? Who were the authorities who granted permission for such unhindered construction near the foothills of Velliangiri? What kind of permissions were given to the Foundation? If posed a question, I am sure Lord Shiva himself would favour the poor tribals who have been granted pattas, over Isha Foundation and its founder. Is the Foundation being protected by the ruling party due to its Hindutva agenda while it overlooks the impact of such unrestrained construction activity in an eco-sensitive area despite protests by tribals and poor people who depend on forests for their livelihood. It is sad that the court was not moved by the plight of the petitioner named Muthamma, a poor tribal woman who sought its intervention? Does it also mean that all those petitioners against the Foundation were unable to establish a prima facie case for injunction against the Foundation and that all petitions against the Foundation did not bear merit for the courts to intervene? Courts must also endeavour to establish the fact as to who supports the Foundation with muscle and money against the genuine grievance of indigenous communities living around the region.

Sunday, July 18, 2010

Seeing REDD in a post-Kyoto framework..

Illegal logging, an obstacle in the race to reduce deforestation

Deforestation of tropical forests releases more carbon than forests outside the tropics. According to IPCC, the carbon mitigating benefits of reducing deforestation are far greater than the benefits of afforestation. Tropical forests account for almost half of the world’s forest area, holding as much carbon in their vegetation and soils as temperate-zone and boreal forests. Trees in tropical forests hold about 50% more carbon per hectare than trees outside the tropics.

Forest management includes maintenance of forest carbon stocks, sustainable harvesting of forest products and equitable distribution of forest wealth among the indigenous people. Climate change regime could increase incursions into the territories of indigenous people without any scope for their participation in forestry activities and harvesting of forestry products. The Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues made recommendations required that new proposals for avoided deforestation or reduced emissions from deforestation address the need for global and national policy reforms guided by the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

Reducing deforestation can mitigate the adverse effects of climate change substantially and for this reason, land, land-use changes and forestry or LULUCF that comprises all land-use activities needs to given utmost importance under a post-2012 climate agreement. Article 3 of the Kyoto Protocol has created a framework for future negotiations although it had left unresolved, critical issues relating to LULUCF and its emissions accounting.

A post-Kyoto climate agreement must address 'avoided deforestation' to achieve the goals set to reduce global warming. Climate change cannot be tackled without addressing issues relevant to avoided deforestation and including them in international climate agreements, a policy known as the Reduced Emissions and Forest Degradation or REDD. REDD can tackle climate change, alleviate poverty and conserve biodiversity. Among many concepts evolved to reduce emissions from deforestation, 'compensated reduction' is recommended to reduce substantial emissions from deforestation facilitating developing country participation in the Kyoto Protocol framework. To implement the compensated reduction plan, governments need to adopt domestic policies that deter private landowners from deforesting their lands.


India, believed that the concept of compensated reduction favored nations with high deforestation rates and therefore proposed the concept of ‘compensated conservation’ that rewards countries for maintaining and increasing their forests as a result of conservation. It also believed that a voluntary fund or enabling fund is required to support capacity building and REDD activities.

The Amazon fund established by Brazilian government supports efforts to reduce deforestation rates by 70% by 2018 through enforcing logging restrictions and land-title reform. Many economists believe that international forest preservation projects be part of global efforts to fight climate change and that industrialized nations need to contribute to this Fund to protect the region from greenhouse gas emissions.