Showing posts with label Land-use change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Land-use change. Show all posts

Sunday, August 2, 2020

Corrigendum to earlier blogpost titled "When Economic interests override Environmental Concerns"



The title “When economic interests override environmental concerns” in one of my blog posts is an objective claim referring to the exclusive issue of demanding a social impact assessment for the Chennai-Salem Corridor at a stage when the original project had been commissioned and was clearly underway. My title presumably does not endorse the view that environmental norms need to be diluted to attract investments.   In retrospect, I am now convinced that the apt title for the blogpost would have been “When political interests override environmental concerns”. The title and the blog post express the futility in reopening environmental and social assessment of a project, that has changed its targets and direction midway to suit political and vested interests. The phrase. ‘Economic interests” specifically refers to those investors who have been awarded contracts in the Bharatmala project and any reopening of assessments could lead to stoppage of work merely because a major route within the state of Tamil Nadu has been changed to suit political purposes.  Essentially, strategic environmental assessment needs to be completed before commission of the projects and contracts have been awarded. It would be legally incorrect to subject the original project whose EIA is completed, at least on paper, to large scale changes that can affect a different region that has not been assessed for environmental and social impacts in the original EIA report.

 

The blog post merely espouses the case of those investors who may face financial constraints if the contracts have been stalled for reasons that are political. It further believes the best option available to all stakeholders would be to proceed with the implementation of original project where environmental impact assessment and social impact assessment have been completed.  Yet, as on date, from details available on the internet, it appears that contracts have been awarded for only 27% of the project and the rest have been delayed for several reasons including COVID-19.

 

Despite all good intentions, the pandemic has brought to standstill many a project including large scale infrastructure projects. In the interregnum, it may be time to review the project and the EIA reports prepared in relation to the entire Bharatmala project with an inquiry into the shelving of Chennai-Madurai Economic Corridor and if the project is to be recommenced post-pandemic, it must follow the original project plan of creating the Chennai-Madurai Economic Corridor, instead of the Chennai-Salem Highway. In any case, acquisition of land for such large-scale infrastructure projects should follow after an extensive EIA report has been prepared since the report shall list out if any agricultural lands are being acquired for the purpose and if any ecologically sensitive areas are being threatened. Further, the EIA report needs to list out any mitigation and adaptation plans are in place subsequent to such acquisition. Acquisition of any land for such large-scale infrastructure projects should be within norms listed for land-use change and if such changes can be justified with a cost-benefit analysis.

 

 

 

 

 

Tuesday, March 10, 2020

When injunction is the norm and not an exception....

The Southern Bench of the National Green Tribunal in a matter relating to a plea to grant stay the celebration of Mahashivarathri at the foothills of the Velliangiri hills located at the elephant corridor. The petitioner believed that lakhs will attend the celebrations disturbing the peaceful existence of wild animals in the area leading to an increase in man-animal conflict in the region. It is indeed surprising that the Tribunal failed to grant a stay of the celebrations even on the preliminary assessment of facts that the venue for conducting the celebrations was indeed within an eco-sensitive region and that there are several petitions against the Isha Foundation pending before various judicial courts in this matter filed every year when the celebrations are due. The plea by the counsel for Isha Foundation that the High Court is seized of the matter and that requisite permissions were already obtained sounds hollow and does not hold water. There is no gainsaying that every year political bigwigs from the ruling party attend the celebrations giving the Foundation much needed publicity. It is therefore, not surprising that there is not a single order against the erring Isha Foundation and the plight of tribals have been sidelined to please the so-called God Man. So, is this dereliction of duty on the part of the National Green Tribunal subsequent to political pressure to connive the illegal activities of the Foundation? It is not clear as to why the lock and seal notice issued against the Foundation not acted upon since 2012, despite state government taking corrective measures against the Foundation. Why was no injunction granted against the construction of 112 feet idol of Lord Shiva on wetlands presumably owned by the Foundation? How did the Foundation even obtain title over land in reserved forest and hill areas? Courts cannot gloss over permissions obtained but examine whether such permissions were within the law and legally appropriate under laws relating to environment protection and forest land use and conversion? Who were the authorities who granted permission for such unhindered construction near the foothills of Velliangiri? What kind of permissions were given to the Foundation? If posed a question, I am sure Lord Shiva himself would favour the poor tribals who have been granted pattas, over Isha Foundation and its founder. Is the Foundation being protected by the ruling party due to its Hindutva agenda while it overlooks the impact of such unrestrained construction activity in an eco-sensitive area despite protests by tribals and poor people who depend on forests for their livelihood. It is sad that the court was not moved by the plight of the petitioner named Muthamma, a poor tribal woman who sought its intervention? Does it also mean that all those petitioners against the Foundation were unable to establish a prima facie case for injunction against the Foundation and that all petitions against the Foundation did not bear merit for the courts to intervene? Courts must also endeavour to establish the fact as to who supports the Foundation with muscle and money against the genuine grievance of indigenous communities living around the region.